Updated 63 Days ago

Being Polite One Door At A Time

Recently I realized I have one of the rudest habits: up until a week or so ago I had never held the door for my coworkers when entering a room or building alongside them.  Be it a man or a woman (see, my rudeness is equal opportunity) I waited for those accompanying me to get the door and breezed right through without a second thought.  I am not sure where my habit came from, but when I realized I may be doing something wrong I began making a vested effort to correct it by grabbing the door when I am the first to reach it (now I am trying to be equal opportunity polite).  

Moving around most office buildings raises the "who gets the door" etiquette question multiple times a day, and I have to think I am not a lone soul, lost in a sea of rudeness.  In my research to find the "official" door etiquette rule, I discovered there is quite a controversy behind the door holding rules especially when gender is a factor.  Some people strongly believe it is sexist for a man to hold the door at any time for a woman no matter if they are on a date or entering a conference room.    

Dr. Beverly Langford, President of the business consulting, training, and coaching firm LMA Communications, wrote "The Etiquette Edge: The Unspoken Rules for Business Success." In her book, she poses the following multiple choice question (pg 13):

"When you approach a doorway at the same time as a person of the opposite sex, the following rules apply:

A) Whoever arrives first should open it and hold it for those who are following.

B) Men should open the doors for women.

C) Women should open doors for men to prove they are no longer oppressed.

D) Always open and hold the door for someone of either sex if that person has his or her hands full."

Dr. Langford gives a definite answer, but what do you, dear internets, think is the right answer? 

About The Author:

Got a story you want to share, or just need someone to talk to? Email Me! melody@toastedrav.com

I have a penchant for pizza, a love of books, and a strong cup of coffee always makes me smile. When I'm not writing for ToastedRav I like long walks on concrete sidewalks, hanging-lamp lit dinners, and a good bottle of Shiraz.


  • CraigDanger 63 Days ago
    E) No matter what a man chooses to do in this situation, he will be wrong
  • mike Staff 63 Days ago
    Um...I'm going to go with answer A.

  • LARed 63 Days ago
    I always do A and D. I find it polite for a man to hold a door for a woman, but don't think he should rush to do it if she is at the door first. This applies to car, as well as, building doors.
  • Skip 63 Days ago
    I think those rules sounds pretty solid to me. Personally, I open and hold doors for anyone that is close by without giving any thought to gender. Likewise, I gratefully accept it when someone returns the gesture and I am sure to thank him or her. For me, that’s common courtesy.

    Of course there is also the convenient reciprocity where there is a door followed by another door as is typical in many restaurants. That way, if someone holds the door for you, you can instantly do the same for him or her.

    Good for you, Melody, for doing the right thing.

    My one pet peeve isn’t directly associated with door etiquette but it does have to do with the “Thank you” part. I was raised to say “Please,” “Thank You” and “You’re Welcome.” I don’t think that is old fashioned, I think its just common courtesy. Nothing drives me more nuts then when you Thank someone and they respond with a nonsensical “Mmmhmmm.”

    Seriously, wth is that? You can’t be troubled to utter a simple polite response that most people offer unconsciously? All that is required is a simple “You’re welcome” or a “No problemo” or something. This ludicrous “Mmmhmmm” might as well be an F Bomb or a swift kick to the tender bits. Hey, you don’t even had to mean it, just at least extend some effort and go through the motions and create the illusion that you aren’t completely self centered and rude.

    Wow, went off on a rant there. At least I didn’t go off on my grocery store pet peeve, which came up last night. I mean, why do people part their cars in the middle of the isle? Are they ignoring the probability that someone else on this planet might like to shop too? How hard is it to . . . see? There I go again. I’ll shut up now.

  • SandyShores 63 Days ago
    So you didn't like my cart obstacle course I set up at Dierbergs? You're no fun!
  • SandyShores 63 Days ago
    As a person in sales, I have always held open doors for people of either sex, hands full or not. I also try to make sure I get to the door first, for the sole purpose of opening it for the other party. In the rare occassion that someone else insists on holding a door open for me, I make sure to show my gratitude- usually accompanied by some sort of comment such as "Wow! Thanks! That was sweet!".
  • AudreyH Staff 63 Days ago
    I hate that awkward time period where you can't tell if it's more annoying to let the door close right before they get to it, or make them hurry to the door because they feel bad that you're holding it.
  • Just Visitin 63 Days ago
    I strive for A & D in business or any public setting. When you are keeping pace with a man, he'll usually indicate he'ld 'like to get that for you' if that's the case. 'Personal' is a whole other matter. This lady believes if he isn't even courteous enough to open your doors... Dump Him. Of course, we ladies are obligated to reciprocate by unlocking his door from the inside of a vehicle for him. :) What a terribly PC day we live in, they have etiquette books on these scenarios, huh?
  • Just Visitin 63 Days ago
    THANK YOU SO MUCH... I went ahead & read the etiquette book recommended above... I totally flunked "Giving Gracious Compliments when they are Deserved". Shame on me!

    Your intuitive perception of the subtleties of the world around us helps us to question... and grow as people! A blog should inform, amuse &/or entertain; which you do stupendously. But it's rare that insight is extended in such a fashion that the writers charisma & inner honesty persuades us to examine our own behaviors & motivations. You achieve this height often; & so, I thank you!

    We'll keep coming back... and perhaps even work a bit on our cart etiquette.
  • margo Staff 59 Days ago
    I also use A & D but I follow a law of exceptions as well. Gender doesn't affect whether I decide to open it or not, but I do believe that a guy should for his girlfriend. Call me old fashioned, but is a gesture of respect (for everyone). I want my man to open the door for me to that no other guy gets the chance to. In that situation, to me, it means I am there with HIM. As for everything else...open the door. No matter what, it is a gesture of kindness. And don't forget this one:

    E. Open the door for old ladies every time. Only open the door for an old man if he has a walking stick. (Careful, sometimes they hit.)

What do you think?

Your Name:

Your Comment:

CAPTCHA (What is this?):

Sometimes submitting a comment can take a while if traffic is high. Please don't hit the submit button more than once.

© Copyright 2008 ToastedRav.com and Bonneville International
An Equal Opportunity Employer all rights reserved